Another day, another reservation policy expansion

Chhattisgarh’s reported move to expand reservations, such that quotas will account for 81% of government jobs and higher education is a sign of things to come. Some weeks ago, SC had allowed the 50% cap to be breached, when it ruled that the EWS quota was constitutional.
Despite the majority ruling that the Indra Sawhney’s 50% cap was to apply to reservations before the EWS quota -namely for SC, ST and OBCs – politicians are unlikely to abide by it. From adequate representation, Chhattisgarh is moving the needle on backward class reservation to proportional representation. Several states are seeking exemption from the 50% cap imposed through judicial review through demands for placing their reservation laws in the Ninth Schedule, which had attempted to insulate a section of laws from judicial oversight.
However, SC had ruled in IR Coelho case(2007) that the Ninth Schedule laws can also be reviewed. But the top court hasn’t yet disposed of the constitutional challenge to the placing of TN’s breach of the 50% cap in the Ninth Schedule. With that remaining pending, will GoI accede to recent demands by Karnataka, Jharkhand and now Chhattisgarh to place their quota laws also under Ninth Schedule?
The bottom line is that the growing reservation demands are proving unmanageable. Soon a situation could come where the non-reserved groups will say 10% EWS reservation is inadequate. Instead of quotas, GoI and states must double down on job creation. Talking about adequate and proportional representation isn’t going to solve the unemployment problem.



The seven who should have remained behind bars: Releasing those convicted of assassinating Rajiv Gandhi is not justice. And Tamil politicians are plain wrong

On the highway to ignominy: India’s implosion in T20 tournaments will continue unless team management admits some deep problems

Anger, power, control, fantasy … savagery: A clinical psychologist writes on what experts know, and don’t know, about the mind of those who commit crimes as horrific as the murder of Shraddha Walkar

Decoding BJP’s Gujarat story: Hindutva became the defining political common-sense in the state thanks to the party’s better statecraft

Let’s be clear on quotas: EWS, like OBC, is about caste, not class. We should stop pretending reservations are about the poor

More judges please: Till collegium’s there GoI must clear names fast

What justice?: Acquittals by higher courts of several death-row convicts speak very poorly of the legal, police system

AAP’s bitter revdi? By championing freebies, Kejriwal may have eased BJP’s path to a comfortable win in Gujarat

8 billion & falling: India, soon to be the world’s most populous country, has a narrow window to encash its demographic dividend

Correct the error: GoI right to appeal SC release of Rajiv killers

Leave a Comment